Coney Island, Treasure Island, FL. A straight answer from licensed MLS data: what buyers actually paid in the last 6 months, how fast, at what share of asking — and how much is for sale today. Updated October 27, 2026.
Single-family homes · Coney Island
QUIET POCKET
Over the last 6 months in Coney Island (Treasure Island), buyers paid a median 100% of the original asking price and 0% of sellers cut price before finding their buyer; 5 are on the market today. Few closings to benchmark against — the specific home's condition and time on market decide your leverage.
5for sale now
0under contract
1sold · 6 mo
29.6months of inventory
0days to contract
$490,000median sold
$273per sq ft
100%of asking
100%of original ask
100% closed at or above the final list price · 0% cut price before selling · 100% went under contract within 14 days · median 100% of the original asking price
Questions buyers in Coney Island ask
Is now a good time to buy a house in Coney Island?
Over the last 6 months in Coney Island (Treasure Island), buyers paid a median 100% of the original asking price and 0% of sellers cut price before finding their buyer; 5 are on the market today. Few closings to benchmark against — the specific home's condition and time on market decide your leverage.
How much under asking are buyers paying in Coney Island?
The median closed sale went for 100% of the original asking price (100% of the final list price after 0% of sellers cut); 100% still sold at or above the final list.
How much competition will I face in Coney Island?
The median house went under contract in 0 days and 100% were gone within two weeks; inventory stands at about 29.6 months.
What do houses cost in Coney Island?
The median closed price over the last 6 months was $490,000 (about 273 per square foot), across 1 sale.
How many houses are for sale in Coney Island right now?
As of October 27, 2026, 5 are for sale today.
What should I offer on a home in Coney Island?
That depends on the specific home — its condition, market time, and the closings around it. Ari Abdi pulls those numbers before you write the offer; send your details above.
Before you offer, I'll pull the actual closings around the home you're watching — what comparable buyers really paid, how long it sat, and how much leverage you have. No obligation, no pressure.