Bay Arbor, Oldsmar, FL. A straight answer from licensed MLS data: what sold in the last 6 months, how fast, at what share of asking — and how much is for sale today. Updated October 27, 2026.
Single-family homes · Bay Arbor
BALANCED
5 houses sold in Bay Arbor (Oldsmar) in the last 6 months at a median 62 days to contract and 97% of the final asking price; 2 are for sale today. Roughly 2.4 months of inventory: a normal, workable market where presentation and pricing matter more than timing.
2for sale now
0under contract
5sold · 6 mo
2.4months of inventory
62days to contract
$575,000median sold
$244per sq ft
97%of asking
0% closed at or above the final list price · 80% cut price before selling · 20% went under contract within 14 days · median 96% of the original asking price
Questions sellers in Bay Arbor ask
Is now a good time to sell a house in Bay Arbor?
5 houses sold in Bay Arbor (Oldsmar) in the last 6 months at a median 62 days to contract and 97% of the final asking price; 2 are for sale today. Roughly 2.4 months of inventory: a normal, workable market where presentation and pricing matter more than timing.
How long does it take to sell a house in Bay Arbor?
Over the last 6 months the median house in Bay Arbor went under contract in 62 days, and 20% were under contract within two weeks.
Do sellers in Bay Arbor get their asking price?
The median sale closed at 97% of the final list price and 96% of the original asking price; 0% sold at or above list and 80% reduced the price before selling.
What do houses sell for in Bay Arbor?
The median closed price over the last 6 months was $575,000 (about $244 per square foot), across 5 sales.
How many houses are for sale in Bay Arbor right now?
As of October 27, 2026, 2 are for sale today.
What would my home in Bay Arbor sell for?
These pages carry market statistics, not valuations — a public estimate of a specific home isn't permitted under the MLS data licence, and it wouldn't be worth much without seeing the house. Send your details above and Ari Abdi will run a personal analysis against these same closings.
Public pages can't carry a valuation of your specific home — the MLS licence doesn't allow it, and a number without seeing the house isn't worth much anyway. Leave your details and I'll run the analysis personally, against these same closings.